Top Rated Wisconsin Car Insurance Companies Based On Customer Reviews

Our knowledge research shows that Wisconsin car owners can save up to 30% to 40% on their auto insurance by comparing quotes from more than two companies. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Car Insurance Ratings & Reviews

Company No Of Reviews Policy Offers Premium Customer support Accessibility Overall
GEICO 30
State Farm 14
Progressive 10
Allstate 7
COUNTRY Financial 7
Farm Bureau 2
National General 1
Nationwide 1
Esurance 1
MetLife 1

Recent auto insurance reviews


GEICO Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
Every time I had to call I was helped immediately, timely and by someone who was located here.

Excellent Customer support
I have never had any issue with customer support or service. They are very prompt and attentive.

Excellent Customer support
One incident sums up Geico customer support for me - my car broke down in the middle of nowhere in TN and I was by myself and completely terrified so I called Geico who informed me that I had roadside assistance and the gentleman stayed on the phone with me, talking to me and trying to calm me down until the sheriff reached me and eventually the tow truck got to my location. He didn't have to stay on the phone but he did. He didn't have to comfort me but he did. This kind of patience and understanding has also been demonstrated whenever I've had questions about my policy.Geico's customer service is really top notch.

Excellent Customer support
I have never had any issues with the customer service with GEICO. They always respond promptly and give me the information I'm looking for. They never try to upsell me or make me purchase anything I don't want.

Excellent Customer support
Whenever I have called, they are prompt and cordial on the phone. I enjoy speaking to them, even though sometimes you have to wait a few minutes, it really isn't bad considering how big of a company they are.

Average Premium
This is the cheapest one I could get in my area and it covers a lot.

Good Premium
My premium with Geico is much lower, and I have more coverage that I would have with a different provider

Excellent Premium
I find my premium pretty fair and affordable with Geico compared to what other companies have quoted me for my needs. The deductible is something I'm comfortable with - and what I can afford- but it's actually about $22 lower than what anyone offered me when I went looking around for insurance

Excellent Premium
My premiums for car insurance through GEICO are much more affordable. I researched a few other companies and found that GEICO provided the most services and discounts for the price.

Excellent Overall
It was hands down the cheapest plan and covers everything I could possibly want them to cover.

Excellent Overall
They provided the best value for the insurance type that I was interested, and had flexible payment options.

Excellent Overall
I opted for Geico because my ex-husband recommended it as a professional company he had been using his "entire life" (his own words) but over time I personally got to experience just how professional the Geico representatives and how attentive they are to detail, especially in times of need so that's why I opt to stay with them year after year now. Plus their rates are cheaper than anywhere I look!

Excellent Overall
I chose GEICO as my auto insurance company because they provided the best rates compared to the other companies I researched.

Excellent Accessibility
As I said the company is easy to communicate and to deal with. Every time I had a need to contact them it was really a smooth experience.

Excellent Accessibility
I have never had issues with this. Their mobile app is very useful, and their employees are very responsive.

Excellent Accessibility
I love that when I call Geico, the representatives are not condescending and they talk to me like I'm human. There is a level of professionalism there that I haven't encountered anywhere else. I also love that they are very patient and very sympathetic. All my interactions with them have been very positive.

Excellent Accessibility
My insurance company is very accessible. I can choose to call or email them and they get back to me in a reasonable amount of time. I have never had a problem with GEICO customer service so far.

Good Accessibility
I can access the insurance company anytime, 24 hours a day, and 7 days a week via the app or by phone.

Good Policy Offers
The insurance company has lower priced with more flexible options

Excellent Policy Offers
Their roadside assistance is practically unmatched everywhere I look and their policy quotes consistently come in cheaper than anyone else, even by a couple of dollars - which makes a huge difference

Excellent Policy Offers
They have an affordable/reasonable 6 months rate and offer lots of perks

Excellent Overall
As I explained earlier Geiko is cheap (well reasonably priced and cheaper than anything else here) and I am very satisfied so far with them.

Excellent Overall
They are very nice and pleasant to deal with. They have always been there when I need them.

Excellent Overall
Excellent customer service is a big part of why I love Geico but also their dedication to always provide the best rates for me, that seem to be more in my favor than theirs - I never ever feel taken advantage of with Geico. So it really comes down to great rates and top-notch people being hired.

Excellent Overall
I like GEICO because it's no fuss and easy to work with them. I also like using GEICO as my insurance provider because everything is very straightforward. I know exactly how much I am paying and what the money is going towards. This company is very transparent.

Excellent Overall
One thing I dislike about this company is that when it comes to things like homeowners insurance, the coverage does not stack up against the competition. The coverage is well below that others have offered and offered a substantially lower rate for that then others did. Also, they outsource the insurance to a 3rd party company, which is an unknown company most of the time. If they could keep their homeowner's insurance in-house, it would make a more appealing package deal.

Excellent Overall
Their website could be a little bit better. Sometimes you have to actually call them because it is not obvious where to look for something on their website.

Excellent Overall
What I dislike about Geico is the fact that they're very quick to threaten cancellation of your policy without reaching out to you. Case in point - I traveled out of the country for 10 days and in that time Geico sent me not one but 2 bills which I couldn't pay because I wasn't home and next thing I know I'm being threatened with cancellation. Of course, we figured it out once I got back but it still irked me a lot.

Excellent Overall
So far I have not had any issues. I do wish my premiums were cheaper but overall in the industry they are some of the cheapest rates I could find. It makes sense since I have a newer car. It would be nice for it to be a little more affordable.

Average Overall
They are cheap and easily accessible. I like the website and the ease of getting someone on the phone. They are well known and trustworthy.


State Farm Auto Insurance Reviews

Good Customer support
Very good customer service by email, text, and phone

Good Customer support
I can always contact customer support. They answer quickly and addresses my needs. I can call, email or simply go to the office. I have never had an issue with them.

Good Premium
It's inexpensive, and it comes out automatically they bundled my policies and vehicles.

Average Premium
I was being charged more with another company. I have a clean driving record and feel that I was paying too much. I decided to make the switch. I don't like overspending and try to get the best possible value.

Good Overall
I went with this company because a friend recommended them. And my agent I met with was amazing and helped me and saved me money

Excellent Overall
I was with another company before and I changed to State Farm because I was getting a better offer. My car is pretty old and I didn't want to keep paying a lot to insure it. I was able to get a better deal with State Farm.

Good Overall
I have been with state farm for about 22 years now. Because I have been with them so long the rates are good for me here, I have looked into other company's but because my credit score is not good I can't switch. I like state farm the claim process is easy and the agents are helpful

Good Accessibility
Very accessible I have personal number and emails to my agent

Good Accessibility
I like that if I email them I usually get an answer the same day. There are times when they reply the next day but not longer than that. I can call and I'm not on hold for very long.

Excellent Policy Offers
I am able to get similar coverage for less than competitors

Good Overall
Amazing company, not very expensive great customer service

Excellent Overall
I have not been given the around. They have been straight with me. If I miss a payment I'm not judged or criticized. They try to work with me and give me good information

Excellent Overall
I wish that they would offer discounts or benefits for staying a customer with them for a long time. I also wish that they could offer benefits for staying a safe driver

Excellent Overall
The company history is strong. We prefer having the local presence and getting the personalized customer service rather than dealing with a random person from a huge company.


Progressive Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
I only dealt with their customer service when initially setting up the policy. I found them friendly, informed, and helpful.

Average Premium
I found that the pricing was comparable to competitors in the market, In fact, it was about 15% lower than my previous insurance company for similar coverage.

Excellent Premium
I will never go to another insurance company, as long as our Progressive agent is still working. She goes above and beyond just selling insurance, personal attachment as well as great respect and admiration for her knowledge and commitment. I have NEVER worked with an agent that comes close to her--they are usually all about numbers, trying to sell you the 'best' plan for "you"...but really they are just looking for a high commission.

Good Premium
The premium with this company was far less than other companies. Plus my deductible will go down a little every month for good driving.

Excellent Overall
My previous insurer of many years dropped me because I went 2 months without having a car. Even though I had another vehicle still insured with them. I had over 15 years of paying premiums without any claims, they refused to insure me due to a 60-day lapse, during which I had NO CAR. An independent agent recommended Progressive and I agreed to it.

Excellent Overall
Well, my mother helped me choose a company when I first started driving. I didn't really do any research, however, I am happy with it.

Good Accessibility
I have not experienced any difficulty with accessibility. I had become accustomed to having an office to go to with my previous insurer and now most of my interaction is through mail or online.

Excellent Accessibility
I like accessibility because they are open 24/7 and not just for calling in claims. Their website is SO easy to use - for payments and to get ID cards.

Excellent Overall
Good pricing and the availability of coverage when another company had turned me down are the main positives I see with Progressive. I have not needed anything more from them and hope not to.

Excellent Overall
I have found nothing at all to dislike about the company at this point. Again, my dealings have mainly been about getting set up. I paid my premium in one yearly payment, so my interactions with them have been very limited


Allstate Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
They truly care about there customers and want what's best for them.

Excellent Premium
They have really low rates. I will always stay with this insurance company!

Excellent Overall
This company has great assistance. They have low prices, amazing customer service, emergency assistance.

Excellent Accessibility
I love how much they care about there customers, their low rates and emergency assistance programs.

Good Policy Offers
Their offers are one of the cheapest around and have a wide variety of assistance!

Excellent Overall
This company has great assistance. They have low prices, amazing customer service, emergency assistance.

Excellent Overall
Sometimes it takes awhile to get ahold of them over the phone.


COUNTRY Financial Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
MY AGENT IS ALWAYS THERE WHEN I NEED HIM. HIS OFFICE IS CONVENIENTLY LOCATED AND I CAN DROP BY AND PICK UP THING, LIKE INSURANCE CARDS, WHEN I NEED THEM INSTEAD OF WAITING FOR SNAIL MAIL. HE IS KIND AND COURTEOUS AND ALWAYS THERE. THE CUSTOMER SERVICE IS ALSO VERY HELPFUL.

Good Premium
I GOT OTHER QUOTES WHEN WE FIRST OPENED THE POLICY AND THEY ARE ALL HIGHER. HOWEVER, OUR RENEWAL IN NOVEMBER HAS INCREASED SOME, SO I AM CONSIDERING SHOPPING AROUND JUST FOR PRICE. THE SERVICE IS EXCELLENT.

Excellent Overall
THEY HAVE GOOD COVERAGE AND ARE RELIABLE. I HAVE WORKED FOR THEM IN THE PAST AND KNOW THEIR PRACTICES. THEY ARE GREAT ON CLAIMS AND THE PRICE WAS GOOD.

Excellent Accessibility
I LIVE ABOUT 15 MINUTES FROM THE AGENCY OFFICE. IT IS IN THE TOWN OVER. I AM IN THE AREA OFTEN SO DROPPING BY WHEN I NEED TO IS NEVER A PROBLEM.

Good Policy Offers
I LIKE THAT I HAVE A DEDICATED AGENT THAT IS THERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS I MAY HAVE. I LOVE THAT I HAVE A NEW CAR COVERAGE THAT WILL GUARANTEE THAT MY ENTIRE LOAN IS COVERED IF THE CAR IS A TOTAL LOSS. GAP COVERAGE ITS CALLED.

Excellent Overall
I LIKE THAT THEIR CUSTOMER SERVICE IS SO GOOD. THEY RESPOND EFFECTIVELY AND IN A TIMELY MANNER. I AM ALWAYS TREATED WITH RESPECT AND KINDNESS. THE AGENT IS ON TOP OF HIS GAME AND GETS THINGS DONE QUICKLY, ALSO.

Excellent Overall
THE ONLY THING I DISLIKE IS THAT MY RATES ARE INCREASING WITH MY NEXT RENEWAL. I WILL BE CALLING THEM TO SEE IF THERE IS A WAY WE CAN DECREASE THE PREMIUM AND SHOPPING RATES IF I HAVE TOL.


Farm Bureau Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
Their customer service is out of this world. When we had to use them last year after a car accident, it was the easiest process ever.

Excellent Policy Offers
I honestly haven't ever looked into other providers so I'm unsure.


National General Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
I haven't had to speak to my agent much since securing a policy. He was friendly and helpful when I initially spoke with him. I did need some paperwork once and he was highly responsive. My experiences have only been positive!


Nationwide Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Policy Offers
The rates are good. They have a vanishing deductible. They have an accident forgiveness. They provide gas if you run out. They have towing.


Esurance Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Premium
I feel our premium is great compared to other companies. The car insurance provider I was with before charged a lot more. I had my home and car bundled through my previous provider and once I switched I pay about $250 less per month.


MetLife Auto Insurance Reviews

Good Overall
It wasn't my choice. I originally was with a broker who had another insurance company for us. However, he closed his shop and merged his accounts over to metlife. We didn't really have a desire to switch to another so we stayed with metlife


2017 © Pansop.com