Top Rated Wisconsin Car Insurance Companies Based On Customer Reviews

Our knowledge research shows that Wisconsin car owners can save up to 30% to 40% on their auto insurance by comparing quotes from more than two companies. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Car Insurance Ratings & Reviews

Company No Of Reviews Policy Offers Premium Customer support Accessibility Overall
USAA 12
State Farm 6
GEICO 6
Allstate 6
West bend Mutual Insurance Company 6

Recent auto insurance reviews


USAA Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
Everytime I have needed to contact USAA with a question or concern i've always received excellent customer service.

Excellent Customer support
I have not had much interaction with USAA's customer support over the years that I have been with the company because I haven't really had any issues. The few times that I have contacted them, I have been happy. They are always quick to respond and resolve my issue in a timely manner.

Good Premium
Compared to the other insurance company I was with USAA offered a lower premium with better coverage.

Excellent Premium
Usaa is cheaper than any other insurance I could find. I have looked at other companies prices several times to compare, but have not found anything cheaper.

Excellent Overall
I bank with USAA and they offered me a good premium on my auto and home insurance. Besides, they are a great bank to do business with

Excellent Overall
I chose USAA because it is cheaper than any other insurance I could find. I have been with them for about 10 years and have both my homeowners and auto insurance with them. I have never had any reason to look elsewhere.

Good Accessibility
Since there isn't a USAA near me, every time I need service I have to do it online or over the phone. If they had more branches it would make it much easier.

Excellent Accessibility
USAA has always been very accessible whenever I need them, which has not been very many times. I never have any problems getting in touch with someone and they always contact me if I request that they do so.

Excellent Policy Offers

Excellent Policy Offers

Excellent Overall
USAA has been a reliable company to do business with. They have excellent customer service are easy to work with.

Excellent Overall
I like that USAA is priced well, that I have never had any issues with billing or other clerical problems, and that they are very responsive and accessible.


State Farm Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
The customer support for my insurance provider is excellent. I have regular check-ups with our insurance agent to ensure that we are satisfied with our coverage and to ascertain if our coverage needs have changed.

Excellent Premium
This company has comparable premiums to other insurance providers in my area, but I am willing to pay even a little higher premium for the customer service I get with my insurance company.

Excellent Overall
One of my good friends from college runs a state farm office in the same town in which I live. Naturally, I signed up to have my insurance provided through his office.

Excellent Accessibility
I very much like that I can call or text my insurance agent at any time, day or night, and get a prompt response.

Excellent Policy Offers
State Farm offers customizable policies to suit every car insurance need. I am able to get the specific policy I want which isn't possible at some other insurance providers.

Excellent Overall
I enjoy working with my insurance agent to make sure that the coverage level we have is sufficient for our vehicle as well as other expenses that may be incurred as a result of an accident.


GEICO Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
Every time I had to call I was helped immediately, timely and by someone who was located here.

Average Premium
This is the cheapest one I could get in my area and it covers a lot.

Excellent Overall
It was hands down the cheapest plan and covers everything I could possibly want them to cover.

Excellent Accessibility
As I said the company is easy to communicate and to deal with. Every time I had a need to contact them it was really a smooth experience.

Excellent Policy Offers

Excellent Overall
As I explained earlier Geiko is cheap (well reasonably priced and cheaper than anything else here) and I am very satisfied so far with them.


Allstate Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
They truly care about there customers and want what's best for them.

Excellent Premium
They have really low rates. I will always stay with this insurance company!

Excellent Overall
This company has great assistance. They have low prices, amazing customer service, emergency assistance.

Excellent Accessibility
I love how much they care about there customers, their low rates and emergency assistance programs.

Good Policy Offers
Their offers are one of the cheapest around and have a wide variety of assistance!

Excellent Overall
This company has great assistance. They have low prices, amazing customer service, emergency assistance.


West bend Mutual Insurance Company Auto Insurance Reviews

Good Customer support
SO our agent that sold us the policy is great. When you have an issue and you need to claim something you have to call a generic 188 number, so its a bit impersonal. You get sent to a claims team, while they are responsive, its a bit impersonal, however, I will say that its professional, and things are taken care of on a timely basis.

Average Premium
West Bend Mutual is somewhat competitive in the pricing, I have noticed that if your claim free in a year, you get 10% back of the annual premium. I will see the negative to the pricing is they don't offer very big incentives for multiple line discounts, however, their is a bit of a discount.

Good Overall
We opted to get our insurance through West Bend Mutual because of a few factors. First, we have two large dogs, one of the dogs has a bit of German Shepherd in his bloodlines, and he has characteristics of that breed as well, markings, coloring etc, and West bend Mutual was one of the only companies that would insure that type of dog breed. Next, we own two properties, so one of our properties is on a lake on two acres of land, and we have small kids, and they so wanted a trampoline, because trampolines cause injuries when not being properly used, they're hard to insure, West Bend Mutual also let us have a trampoline at our secondary property, upon a safety inspection of the trampoline. So West Bend Mutual easily earned our business by not being a typical insurance company and being picky about what they did and didn't insure.

Good Accessibility
I like our agent who sold us the policy, I don't care for the fact that when you have a question with the actual insurance you call a generic 1800 number, that gets to be a bit impersonal at times. The best scenario would be having the same contact person for all your insurance needs, everything from selling the policy to claims, etc.

Excellent Policy Offers

Good Overall
What I like about West Bend Mutual is if you do have an accident, claim or incident, the rates don't immediately go up, so that's helpful in multiple ways, after an accident the last thing you want to see in your mailbox, right away is your insurance going up! As far as insurance companies go, they seem to fair in what they pay out too.


2017 © Pansop.com