Top Rated New Jersey Car Insurance Companies Based On Customer Reviews

Our knowledge research shows that New Jersey car owners can save up to 30% to 40% on their auto insurance by comparing quotes from more than two companies. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Car Insurance Ratings & Reviews

Company No Of Reviews Policy Offers Premium Customer support Accessibility Overall
GEICO 18
USAA 12
Progressive 6
Allstate 6
State Farm 6
Erie Insurance 6

Recent auto insurance reviews


GEICO Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
I have had no problems with Geico's customer service, but I really haven't had any issues with any insurance company's customer service. They are usually easy to get in touch with.

Excellent Customer support
Well one time I parked my car and stayed inside and slept - during the daytime while my lights were on, and killed battery - I called them up for roadside assistance and got one 1 hour - not bad.

Excellent Customer support
Having 24/7 access to customer service is fantastic. Vehicles cannot pick and choose when they will break down or get into an accident. Things happen and Geico is always there to help no matter what time it is. I have even called to pay my bill at 2 am. Very convenient.

Excellent Premium
It is cheaper than other companies offer. For my Geico insurance, it is just about 100$ a month, but with other companies like Allstate and Progressive, it would be closer to 150$ a month.

Average Premium
This is the lowest. Every year I check and compare with others. Geico cheapest every time

Good Premium
The premium is ok. I honestly did not compare to other companies because I applied for Geico through a family member who is an agent. It is lower than my previous premium at State Farm, so that is a plus.

Excellent Overall
I chose Geico because they offered the lowest rates. Originally I was going to use Progressive, but I was able to save about 60$ or so a month by using Geico, so I chose them instead. I don't really have a preference for either though, I just go by price.

Excellent Overall
It's the freaking cheapest.Every year I check and compare with others. Geico is the cheapest everytime

Good Overall
I chose them, initially because this company offered me the lowest rate for my auto insurance with the best payment options.

Excellent Accessibility
I am satisfied with the accessibility of my insurance company. I have had no trouble whatsoever getting in touch with the company when I need them or want to speak to someone.

Excellent Accessibility
24/7 I do not use the app - I think that is stupid. Would rather talk to somebody. But sometimes in a dead zone,

Good Accessibility
As stated above I have had nothing but positive interactions with my company, thus far. I like the kind, knowledgeable and friendly manner I always receive. I always feel comfortable and confident when dealing with them.

Excellent Policy Offers
They are the same as any other insurance company, but they are slightly cheaper than the other big name insurance companies, like progressive and Allstate.

Good Policy Offers
I love the insurance compaines features as Lower rate, no-fault injury, uninsured motorist coverage, collision,24/7 Customer service and roadside assistance.

Excellent Overall
I like that I can get a quote and my insurance coverage did online, without any issues or having to call anyone. It is a simple, easy to use service that I can customize, and it is cheap.

Excellent Overall
I like Geico - because it's the cheapest and they are available 24/7 365.

Good Overall
The people, the price, the little extra offers all are factors in what I like about the company. I feel my car is safe in their hands.


USAA Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
Everytime I have needed to contact USAA with a question or concern i've always received excellent customer service.

Excellent Customer support
Excellent customer service! I have never had a single issue contacting USAA or understanding anything. They explain in detail and easy to understand and make sure they have covered all questions and beyond. They are friendly, and I have never had someone rude or demeaning with USAA.

Good Premium
Compared to the other insurance company I was with USAA offered a lower premium with better coverage.

Excellent Premium
Most other companies provide similar insurance, but with our coverage, we have premium, which provides accident assist. They will cover the cost of the vehicle plus 20% cash value towards a new vehicle. So the $500 deductible works great for us.

Excellent Overall
I bank with USAA and they offered me a good premium on my auto and home insurance. Besides, they are a great bank to do business with

Excellent Overall
My husband is a Veteran. We receive multiple discounts for having multiple accounts with them, along with great rates due to his prior military service.

Good Accessibility
Since there isn't a USAA near me, every time I need service I have to do it online or over the phone. If they had more branches it would make it much easier.

Excellent Accessibility
Although the nearest physical location is a few hundred miles away, we have access to everything we need from our mobile devices (app), online, or over the phone.

Excellent Policy Offers
They provide excellent coverage and policy discounts are great through USAA.

Excellent Overall
USAA has been a reliable company to do business with. They have excellent customer service are easy to work with.

Excellent Overall
I like the excellent customer service, prices, and options. Also, the ease of access is phenomenal.


Progressive Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
When my husband was in an accident almost a year ago, Progressive paid us immediately $4100 for us to get a car. They were fast and on top of things!

Good Premium
The premium for Progressive was way cheaper than USAA, GEICO, and of course State Farm. State Farm was the most expensive one for me and my family, about $200 extra. While USAA and GEICO were about $100 more for full coverage.

Excellent Overall
I went with Progressive because they were the cheapest for full coverage. I have had GEICO and USAA before, but once I compared all of those auto insurance companies together, Progressive was the cheapest. Plus, when my husband had a car accident from his coworker hitting him, Progressive paid us immediately for us to get our Mazda 03 2008.

Good Accessibility
I like that it's not an hour away. I like that we just have to get onto the highway and drive like 5-10 minutes from there until we are at the insurance company. What I dislike is the traffic in Nashville.

Good Policy Offers
Full coverage with Progressive compared to USAA and GEICO was a least $100 cheaper!

Excellent Overall
Overall, Progressive is a great company! They are affordable for the working class which is amazing! They also handle all of their claims fast.


Allstate Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
THEY VERY NICE. THEY WILL HELP WITH ALL YOUR NEED. THEY LISTEN TO YOU AND THEY UNDERSTAND YOU. I LOVE THEM.

Excellent Premium
THIS IS GOOD THE OTHER IS HIGHER. I LOVE THIS PRICE. I WOULD TELL MY FRIEND ABOUT

Excellent Overall
I LIKE ALLSTATE BECAUSE THEY CARE ABOUT. THEY HELP PICK THE BEST THING FOR YOUR AUTO INSURANCE AND THE PRICE. THEY MAKE YOU FEEL LIKE FAMILY.

Good Accessibility
I LIKE HOW THEY TAKE THE OUT OF YOUR ACCOUNT EVERY MONTH AT THE SAME TIME. THROUGH THEIR E-PAY ACCOUNT.

Excellent Overall
THE PRICE AND THE WAY THEY DO YOUR CLAIM SO FAST AND EASY THAT GOOD FOR ME.


State Farm Auto Insurance Reviews

Bad Customer support
I really don't have much contact at all with customer support I have never filed a claim so my need to communicate has been very limited. I have not had a need to talk or call them at all. I am very concerned about the rate increases and like I said if it continues will most definitely be checking for prices from other companies

Bad Premium
I was a little unhappy my policy goes up every year even though I have never filed a claim. My house insurance has went up nearly forty dollars and this year my car insurance went up by around fifty dollars every six months if they continue I am going to change to a different company. I am become very unhappy with them since the rate increase does not seem justified

Bad Overall
At the time I choose this company I was going through a divorce and had to change to my own policy. I was able to combine my house insurance with my car insurance and obtain a discount. I also choose it because it is a name brand company that has been around for a long time. They gave me a great quote so I changed to them I have been with them ever since

Bad Accessibility
The agent I got my insurance from is very close to my house so I can't complain about that at all it is almost around the corner even though I think most transactions are handled by claims people so I don't know how much this matters now in these times.

Bad Overall
I liked that they had been around forever and that they had a pretty good reputation. I liked the ease of billing and that you could pay your insurance in either monthly payments or break the six month period into two different payments. I like that you can pay this online through the website that is easy to use.


Erie Insurance Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
Erie insurance has up to the minute excellent customer service. They believe their customers are their number one priority. They will do whatever it takes to help the customer.

Excellent Premium
The premiums compared to the other auto insurance companies are about 200.00 less a year. It is very affordable for many good drivers.

Excellent Overall
Erie insurance is very reliable and helps me with all of my travel needs. They have had a great reputation for many years. I recommend the insurance to everyone.

Excellent Accessibility
Everyone time I cal Erie insurance they are very prompt to pull up my records. They make sure to try and resolve any issue that I may have.

Excellent Policy Offers
They have lower deductibles and lower perennials for good drivers

Excellent Overall
Erie Insurance offers a lot of different plans for all kinds of drivers. They want their customers to be as satisfied as possible. They value me as number one.


2017 © Pansop.com