Top Rated California Car Insurance Companies Based On Customer Reviews

Our knowledge research shows that California car owners can save up to 30% to 40% on their auto insurance by comparing quotes from more than two companies. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Car Insurance Ratings & Reviews

Company No Of Reviews Policy Offers Premium Customer support Accessibility Overall
GEICO 24
State Farm 12
Progressive 8
Esurance 7
Allstate 7
Garrison Insurance 7
Timmco 7
Nationwide 1
Liberty Mutual 1

Recent auto insurance reviews


GEICO Auto Insurance Reviews

Good Customer support
They answer the phone and provide good customer service. I have not had any problems with them on the phone. My only complaint is that the roadside assistance can be a bit slow.

Excellent Customer support
I only had to talk to a person once when getting insurance that was 10 years ago they gave me a price, I switched to them and haven't had to deal with them or any hassle sense. They also make online payments really easy.

Average Customer support
I haven't had any customer service experiences with the company. Everything I do is online.

Excellent Customer support
I have always had a good experience with Geico. I called them about the windshield repair, and they told me to just go online via the app and arrange an appointment that was convenient for me.

Good Premium
It seems to be about the same. I have shopped around for other insurance, and for what I am paying, it seems to be the same.

Excellent Premium
My old insurance it would change every time I paid sometimes it would be 500 sometimes 700. With Geico, it hasn't changed in 10 years. So it's a lot less of a burden when it comes time to pay my insurance.

Average Premium
I think it's about the same cost I would expect from another company. I generally get a couple quotes to check prices before I go with a company.

Excellent Premium
Geico was the cheapest option for auto insurance. Many other companies wanted me to pay hundreds more for the same coverage.

Good Overall
They had the best prices and it was easy to register with them online. I have been with them for years and I have not had any problems.

Excellent Overall
Geico had really low prices that don't fluctuate. It's also a lot less of a hassle because I don't have to deal with an agent for the purchasing of the insurance.

Average Overall
My wife wanted to get insurance with them for some reason and so I got on the website and set it up.

Good Accessibility
They are easy to reach and they do not put me on hold when I call. They make me feel like a valued customer, and I have little to complain about.

Excellent Accessibility
If something were to go wrong all I would have to do is call them. If I ever did have a claim I feel like they would take care of it without any hassle.

Average Accessibility
I like being able to administer my policy online without having to talk or deal with anyone. The web interface is good so there is no problem there.

Excellent Accessibility
I can chat with an agent online, I can call them or email. They are very accessible when I need them.

Excellent Policy Offers
My insurance is the same or better and it's cost about the 1/3rd the price of my old insurance.

Good Overall
They are reputable and easy to contact. I have not had any issues with them, and they seem just as good as any other company.

Excellent Overall
It's hassle-free. I don't have to deal with anything. It's cheap. If anything goes wrong I am covered by one of the biggest insurance companies. Payments are easy. They don't send me a bunch of stuff in the mail.

Average Overall
I like the Gecko mascot. I like the website is easy to use and navigate to pay my premium.

Excellent Overall
There has been nothing negative about Geico so far. I have been a customer for 7 years and I have nothing to be upset about.

Good Overall
Like I said above, their roadside assistance is a bit slow. I have had to wait for hours for them to show up.

Excellent Overall
I can't find anything I really don't like. Some of their commercials I don't like besides that I can't think of anything.

Average Overall
So far there is nothing to dislike about the company. I suppose if their premiums were even lower that would be better.

Good Overall
I think they offer good service. Price is a big deal to me and they seem to excel at that. Customer service has been solid, and they readily handled my minor fender bender.


State Farm Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
They always went out of their way to help and have looked into an issue that has arisen in the past.

Good Premium
It costs a little more than most other companies but at least I know they're reliable and pay and have proof to back that up.

Excellent Premium
They seem to offer the best price for full coverage and offer a discount for bundling.

Excellent Overall
My parents and grandparents have used them for years without problems. I've myself have used them for awhile now and have experienced the same.

Excellent Accessibility
I like that there's an office right by, so I could walk there if I didn't have my car at the time. They have normal business hours and the one by my house is in it a house itself, not an office so seems more relatable and less corporate.

Excellent Accessibility
They are extremely customer oriented. They are pleasant and cooperative and I always feel that they have my best interests at heart. They took a chance on me years ago and now I am loyal to them. I will never switch companies, even to save a few bucks.

Good Policy Offers
They're stable and always pay out when they're supposed too as opposed to progressive for instance who will do anything not to pay

Excellent Overall
How reliable they've been for not only me but most of my family. I haven't heard of any significant issues from friends either, or even strangers.

Excellent Overall
My only complaint is that company policy says that they will not insure flat roofs. Therefore, I cannot get my homeowner's through them. I had to go with another company. I guess the risk of fire is too high for their underwriters. If I were able to get homeowners through them, then I would be eligible for some multi-policy discounts and perhaps save a few dollars.

Excellent Overall
So far there's nothing I really dislike about them that I can think of off the top of my head worth noting.

Excellent Overall
State Farm is a well know, trusted company. They were very easy to start a policy with and they renew every six months with no issues, I just get my new card in the mail. My price may go up a little but never anything drastic. They are easy to get in touch with and offer exactly what I need at a great price.

Good Overall
The company seems trustworthy as they have been around for many years. I feel they will be there when I run into issues. They have funny commercials.


Progressive Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
EVERY TIME I HAVE TO CALL INSTEAD OF USE THE WEB SERVICE, THEY ARE HELPFUL AND RESPONSIVE. THEY MAKE SURE TO HELP ME WITH ANYTHING THAT I NEED.

Excellent Premium
I FEEL THE PREMIUM IS VERY REASONABLE FOR THE COVERAGE THAT I NEED. FURTHERMORE, THE COST HAS REMAINED THE SAME YEAR AFTER YEAR WHICH I APPRECIATE.

Excellent Overall
PROGRESSIVE HAD VERY REASONABLE RATES AS WELL AS THE OPTIONS I WAS LOOKING FOR. THE WEBSITE IS VERY USER FRIENDLY AND IT'S SO SIMPLE TO RENEW MY POLICY.

Excellent Accessibility
I REALLY LIKE HOW MUCH YOU CAN DO FROM THE WEBSITE. SELF-SERVICE FITS MY LIFESTYLE THE BEST AND YOU CAN DO ALMOST ANYTHING FROM THE SITE.

Excellent Policy Offers
IT OFFERS FULL COVERAGE PLUS COVERS SPECIFIC MODS FOR MY WHEELCHAIR FOR MY CAR.

Good Policy Offers
They also partnered with my home insurance and gave a multi-policy discount

Excellent Overall
GENERALLY SPEAKING, PROGRESSIVE IS WONDERFUL. FROM CUSTOMER SERVICE TO PRICES TO COVERAGE OFFERED, THEY ARE THE BEST AND I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THEM.

Excellent Overall
I REALLY CANNOT THINK OF ANYTHING OR PINPOINT SOMETHING I DON'T LIKE ABOUT THEM.


Esurance Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
I do most of my communication through the app. I get a response right away and it is usually from the same representative.

Excellent Premium
The second cheapest quote we obtained was Geico Insurance, and they were $60 more per month.

Excellent Overall
They're 100% online. I've never had to step foot in an office to take anything to the post office. Originally it was because they're MUCH cheaper than everyone else, but I stay because customer service is great also.

Excellent Accessibility
Everything is online. I never need to go to a location.

Excellent Overall
Everything over the past 3 years has been smooth sailing. We've been through two total loss accidents and as far as insurance on our side it was wrapped up and paid out within 10 days.

Good Overall
I have had no reason to dislike the company. So far, I can only give a positive review and hope the great service will continue. I am not opposed to switching companies. I have just never had a reason to change.

Excellent Overall
Everyone wishes they paid less.. But other than that I am completely satisfied.


Allstate Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
I had an issue with a lost check I sent in for payment a few years ago and customer service handled it to my satisfaction quickly without a lapse in my coverage.

Excellent Premium
I have compared my policy with Allstate to other companies and I feel what I pay for what I get is average.

Excellent Overall
My parents used Allstate and I just went with them because of that and have since developed a personal relationship with the local agent.

Excellent Accessibility
Allstate offers a variety of means to contact them, Phone, Email online chat and right through their app. I am very satisfied with the options.

Excellent Policy Offers
I feel the policy offering is just as good as other companies.

Excellent Overall
Allstate is easy to work with when filing a claim and customer service is top notch and has solved my issues quickly and to my satisfaction.

Excellent Overall
I really do not have any dislikes about Allstate they have done everything to my satisfaction when I needed them to, So I can't really say anything bad about them.


Garrison Insurance Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
If you call the company you get an employee based in Texas. The employees generally understand their products and if you have a problem that an employee doesn't understand a supervisor will call you to help you resolve the issue. I trust them to solve my issues and be courteous while doing it.

Good Premium
Like I said, I'm sure the premium is higher than other companies but I know USAA will pay out, and pay out without a lot of shady business trying to deny claims, etc. I have had them for over 20 years. They have paid out for my car being stolen, for being damaged in a tornado, and for accidents. I will pay more for that level of assurance.

Excellent Overall
Garrison is the auto insurance company that covers cars in my area through the USAA insurance and banking portal. I have been a customer of USAA for years and their services are very good. I have had other types of insurances, accounts, investments with them and I trust them fully. The insurance might be slightly more expensive but it is a quality product that doesn't try to short payments to distressed homeowners and vehicle owners during natural disasters like those OTHER insurance companies do.

Excellent Accessibility
My insurance company is a phone call away, I speak to the main policy holder, USAA, and I speak to someone in America. They are very accessible and responsive.

Excellent Policy Offers
I'm sure they all offer the same types of automotive insurance policies.

Excellent Overall
USAA is known by military families all over the country for their superior offerings and for the fact that even in natural disasters, such as the hurricane flood in Katrina, and more recently Houston, the insurance company will honor its claims and pay out without trying to short shift its customers.

Excellent Overall
There is nothing I dislike about this company, the company is honorable, kind, helpful, smart, accessible, offers multiple products, has fair rates, has good CD interest rates, gives cash back to the members if there is extra money in the pool at the end of the year and THEY PAY THEIR CLAIMS. What is not to like?


Timmco Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Customer support
I am very satisfied with their fast and responsive customer service. When we needed to provide proof of insurance to our lien holder, the representative was able to email a copy to the credit union within the hour.

Good Premium
The premium is slightly more than the cost quoted by other companies for the same coverage, but we chose our company because of its track record and known reliability. We felt it was worth the extra money.

Excellent Overall
We have used Safeco insurance for many years and they are reliable and fairly priced. When we moved and had to find a new provider, we found Timmco, a Safeco representative, and have been very happy with them.

Excellent Accessibility
I very happy about the accessibility of our insurance company. I have been able to contact an agent by phone immediately every time I have needed to. They have been able to help us with our requests on the same day.

Excellent Policy Offers
Our company offers policies ranging from liability to full collision. They also offer home and renter's policies, bundled in for a lower rate.

Excellent Overall
Timmco's agents are great- they do their job pleasantly and accurately. We have had a great experience with them during the year and a half they have been our insurance provider.

Excellent Overall
I really have no complaints about the company. They are friendly and responsive. It's true that we pay slightly more for our policy but in my opinion, it's been worth it.


Nationwide Auto Insurance Reviews

Excellent Premium
The premium is fair. It is the best rate that I was able to get and for the value, I cannot complain.


Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance Reviews

Good Policy Offers
This company offers bundling packages and discounts for safe driving


2017 © Pansop.com